Workday HCM alternatives in 2027: 8 tools compared
Workday HCM: Enterprise human capital management platform for HR, payroll, talent, learning and workforce planning, with AI agents. People look for alternatives when they need a lower price, a free plan or a better fit for a specific job.
These 8 tools cover similar ground. Each entry explains who it suits, how pricing works and what to watch out for.
Key takeaways
ADP Workforce Now: mid-size and larger companies that want payroll, HR, benefits and time tracking from one established provider with strong compliance support.
BambooHR: small and mid-size companies that want easy, well-designed HR software to replace spreadsheets, especially in the US.
Deel: companies hiring contractors or employees in other countries, especially those without local entities.
Gusto: uS small businesses, especially first-time employers, that want payroll and taxes handled without an accountant running them.
HiBob: mid-size, international companies that want modern HR software focused on employee experience and culture.
Justworks: uS small businesses that want better benefits, payroll and HR support without building an HR team.
Paychex Flex: uS businesses of all sizes that want payroll and HR services with access to human support from a long-established provider.
Paylocity: uS small and mid-size companies that want payroll and HR in one platform with strong employee engagement tools.
ADP Workforce Now combines payroll and tax, HR records, benefits administration, time and attendance and talent management in one platform, built for companies with roughly 50 to 1,000+ employees. It includes compensation benchmarking and AI that flags unusual payroll changes, answers questions and helps resolve issues. It's sold in three packages, Select, Plus and Premium, with pricing by quote.
Paid
Quote-based. Three packages: Select (payroll and HR), Plus (adds benefits administration) and Premium (adds time and attendance). Contact ADP for pricing.
Who it suits: Mid-size and larger companies that want payroll, HR, benefits and time tracking from one established provider with strong compliance support.
What we like
Established provider with decades of payroll and compliance experience
Payroll, HR, benefits and time in one platform
Scales from mid-size companies to large organisations
Payroll and HR services available in more than 140 countries through ADP
Watch out for
Pricing isn't published; you need a quote
Benefits and time tracking require the higher packages
Setup and administration take more effort than small-business tools
BambooHR replaces HR spreadsheets with a central employee database and self-service app. It covers employee records, workflows and approvals, time off, hiring and onboarding, benefits tracking, employee satisfaction surveys and reporting. Pro adds performance management and more people tools, and Elite adds advanced features and support. Payroll and benefits administration are available as add-ons for US employees.
Paid
25 employees or fewer: flat $250 (Core), $425 (Pro) or $650 (Elite) a month. Over 25 employees: from about $10.25 (Core), $17.50 (Pro) and $25 (Elite) per employee/month, with volume and non-profit discounts. Payroll and Benefits Administration (US only) are add-ons; 15% off when bundled.
Who it suits: Small and mid-size companies that want easy, well-designed HR software to replace spreadsheets, especially in the US.
What we like
Very easy for HR teams and employees to use
Strong hiring and onboarding tools
Good reporting and a clean employee experience
Flat monthly pricing for companies with 25 or fewer employees
Volume and non-profit discounts
Watch out for
Payroll and benefits administration are US-only add-ons
Pricing isn't self-serve; you request a quote
Performance management needs Pro
Flat small-company prices are high for very small teams
Deel lets companies hire anyone, anywhere. Its Employer of Record (EOR) service legally employs people for you in more than 130 countries, handling contracts, payroll, benefits and compliance, so you don't need a local entity. It also pays and manages international contractors, offers Contractor of Record to shift misclassification risk, runs global payroll where you have entities, provides a US PEO, and includes HR and talent tools.
Paid
Starting prices: contractor management $49 per contractor/month, Contractor of Record $325/month, US PEO $125 per employee/month, Employer of Record $599 per employee/month. Talent tools from $14 per worker/month. Global payroll quoted by country.
Who it suits: Companies hiring contractors or employees in other countries, especially those without local entities.
What we like
Hire in many countries without setting up entities
Gusto runs payroll for US small businesses and handles the paperwork around it. It calculates pay, withholds and files federal, state and local payroll taxes, pays employees and contractors by direct deposit, and files year-end W-2s and 1099s. On top of payroll it offers onboarding, benefits administration, time tracking and HR tools. Pricing is a monthly base fee plus a fee for each person you pay.
Paid
Simple: $49/month + $6 per person. Plus: $80/month + $12 per person. Premium: $180/month + $22 per person. Contractors are billed at your plan's per-person rate, only in months you pay them. US payroll.
Who it suits: US small businesses, especially first-time employers, that want payroll and taxes handled without an accountant running them.
What we like
Very easy to set up and run, even for first-time employers
Payroll taxes and year-end forms filed for you
Contractors only cost money in months you pay them
Employees get a self-service app for pay stubs and documents
Benefits, onboarding and HR in the same system as payroll
Watch out for
US payroll only
Simple covers payroll in one state; multi-state needs Plus
Time tracking starts on Plus
Per-person fees add up as you grow
HR features are lighter than dedicated HR platforms
HiBob's platform, called Bob, is an HRIS for mid-size and growing companies, especially those with people in several countries. It covers employee records, onboarding, time off, performance reviews, compensation planning, engagement surveys, analytics and a payroll hub, with UK payroll available directly. Its social, engaging interface helps distributed teams connect. Pricing is by quote.
Paid
Quote-based. HiBob doesn't publish prices; you request a demo and quote based on your company size and the modules you need (core HR, payroll, performance, compensation and more).
Who it suits: Mid-size, international companies that want modern HR software focused on employee experience and culture.
What we like
Modern, engaging interface employees actually use
Strong for global and distributed teams
Good analytics and reporting
Performance and compensation tools built in
Watch out for
Pricing isn't published; you need a quote
Payroll is built in for the UK and connected elsewhere through the Payroll Hub
Justworks is best known as a PEO (professional employer organisation). By co-employing your staff, it gives small businesses access to large-group health insurance and other benefits, runs payroll and taxes, and helps with compliance and HR, all at published per-employee prices. It also offers standalone payroll for companies that don't want a PEO, and Employer of Record services for hiring abroad.
Paid
Payroll $50/month base + $8 per employee/month. PEO Basic $79 and PEO Plus $124 per employee/month, no base fee. Global EOR $599 per employee/month. Add-ons such as time tracking ($8 per employee/month).
Who it suits: US small businesses that want better benefits, payroll and HR support without building an HR team.
What we like
Access to large-group benefits that small companies often can't get alone
Transparent, published pricing
Payroll, benefits and compliance in one service
24/7 support
Watch out for
The PEO model, where Justworks co-employs your staff, isn't for everyone
PEO pricing per employee is higher than payroll-only services
Mainly for US employees; global hiring uses a separate, pricier EOR product
Paychex Flex is Paychex's online payroll and HR platform. It runs payroll and tax filing, and adds HR tools, employee benefits, retirement plans, time and attendance, workers' compensation insurance and payment processing as needed. Businesses can manage everything themselves or get help from Paychex payroll specialists and HR professionals, and larger companies can use Paychex's PEO. Pricing is quoted based on company size and services.
Paid
Quote-based. Paychex prices Paychex Flex by employee count and the services you choose, from small-business payroll to HR, benefits, time and attendance and PEO. Contact Paychex for a quote.
Who it suits: US businesses of all sizes that want payroll and HR services with access to human support from a long-established provider.
What we like
Broad range of payroll, HR and benefits services
Access to payroll specialists and HR professionals
Scales from very small businesses to large companies
One provider for payroll, benefits, insurance and retirement
Watch out for
Pricing isn't published; you need a quote
Add-ons and services increase the total cost
More complex than simple payroll apps for very small teams
Paylocity is an all-in-one HR and payroll platform for US businesses. It runs payroll and taxes, and adds benefits administration, time and labour, talent management, learning, expense management and HR consulting. It's known for employee engagement features such as Community, a social intranet for announcements and recognition, and a strong mobile app. Pricing is per employee per month, by quote.
Paid
Quote-based. Paylocity charges per employee per month based on the modules and services you choose, with no tiered price jumps as you grow. Implementation may be billed separately. Request a demo for pricing.
Who it suits: US small and mid-size companies that want payroll and HR in one platform with strong employee engagement tools.
What we like
Strong employee engagement and communication tools
Broad set of payroll and HR modules in one platform
Good mobile app
Per-employee pricing with no tier jumps as you scale
Every tool on this list does the core job of HR & payroll software, so it can replace Workday HCM for most people.
We weighed pricing and free plans, ease of use, and the trade-offs you take on when switching.
Pricing comes from each vendor’s public pricing page and changes often, so confirm before you buy.
Buying guide: what to check before you switch
HR and payroll platforms run payroll and taxes, manage benefits, onboarding, time off and employee records. Some specialise in hiring and paying people in other countries.
Countries and states supported
Payroll tax filing
Benefits administration
Onboarding and time off
Prices and features change often. Check each vendor’s website for current plans before you buy.